Student Scholarship

Document Type

Research Paper

Abstract

The doctrine of grace serves as a foundational and often controversial pillar of the Christian church, necessitating constant reconsideration throughout history. This document explores the historical evolution of the concept, beginning with its roots in the Old and New Testaments. In the Old Testament, grace is closely tied to God's steadfast love and the covenant with Israel. However, St. Paul emerged as the first profound Christian interpreter, defining grace as a free, undeserved gift from God made manifest through Jesus Christ. For Paul, salvation is achieved through faith and grace alone, explicitly excluding human works or merit as a basis for redemption. 

St. Augustine further developed this theology while defending it against Pelagius, who argued that humans possessed the natural capacity to choose good without divine intervention. Augustine maintained that since the fall of Adam, the human will is bound by sin and requires the irresistible power of grace to be healed and directed toward God. By the thirteenth century, St. Thomas Aquinas introduced a more complex, systematic approach, categorizing grace into various types such as sanctifying, operative, and co-operative. Unlike Paul and Augustine, Aquinas suggested a synthesis where human merit could earn additional grace, though he still attributed the initial movement toward God to divine initiative. 

The Reformation marked a significant return to Pauline thought through Martin Luther. Luther rejected the medieval system of merits and indulgences, rediscovering justification as a personal relationship based on sola fide, or faith alone. He emphasized that grace is God's favorable disposition toward the sinner, not a substance or quality residing within the soul. By tracing these theological shifts, the document concludes that while the interpretation of grace has fluctuated between divine power and human cooperation, it remains the essential story of God's saving work.

Research Highlights

  • The Problem: The author addresses the historical development and theological variations of the doctrine of grace in the Christian church, specifically the tension between grace as a free gift versus a reward for human merit. 

  • The Method: The study uses a comparative historical framework to analyze the writings of four primary theologians: St. Paul, St. Augustine, St. Thomas Aquinas, and Martin Luther. 

  • Qualitative Finding: St. Paul and Martin Luther define grace as an unmerited personal relationship and divine favor; St. Augustine interprets it as an irresistible power and the infusion of love; St. Thomas Aquinas introduces a systematic division of grace into operative and co-operative types where human works can merit additional grace. 

  • Finding: The Reformation marked a theological return to the original Pauline concept of sola fide, rejecting the Medieval synthesis of grace and merit established by Aquinas.

Publication Date

5-1967

Creative Commons License

Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License

Faculty Sponsor

Archive

Download

Share

COinS