Student Scholarship

Document Type

Research Paper

Abstract

This case study examines the organizational structure and strategic operations of the oil lobby during the 86th Congress, specifically focusing on the Western Oil and Gas Association. The primary objective of the association was to secure amendments to the Mineral Leasing Act of 1920 to increase acreage limitations for oil and gas exploration in Alaska. At the time, existing laws restricted companies to 100,000 acres under lease, which the industry argued was insufficient given the extreme costs, physical risks, and vast geographical scale of the Alaskan frontier. The association initially proposed a limit of one million acres to incentivize investment and allow for competitive exploration against foreign markets. 

The narrative details the tactical role of the lobbyist, Frank Rogers, who facilitated the legislative process by drafting the bill, securing congressional sponsorship from the Alaskan delegation, and navigating the technical requirements of committee hearings. The study highlights the complexities of the legislative environment, including a significant departmental report from the Department of the Interior that opposed the initial bill due to concerns over acreage concentration and potential monopolies. This opposition led to a compromise where the proposed limit was reduced to 600,000 acres. 

Despite successfully passing through both the House and Senate, the initial legislation was vetoed by the President following a recommendation from the Department of the Interior. However, the lobby persisted into the second session, eventually seeing the Alaskan provisions incorporated into a larger omnibus bill. The study concludes that while lobbyists are driven by self-interest, they serve a vital role in the democratic process by providing technical expertise, organizing witnesses, and offering essential information to lawmakers.

Research Highlights

  • Primary Figures: Frank W. Rogers, lobbyist for the Western Oil and Gas Association; Senator E.L. Bartlett, Senator Ernest Gruening, and Representative Ralph H. Rivers of Alaska; and Senator Gordon L. Allott of Colorado. 

  • Key Events: Western Oil and Gas Association drafted legislation to increase Alaskan acreage limits in late 1958; Bills H.R. 6940 and S. 1855 were introduced May 5, 1959; the Department of the Interior issued a negative report and suggested dividing Alaska for oil purposes; President Eisenhower vetoed H.R. 6940; a compromise was eventually included in an omnibus bill during the second session of the 86th Congress. 

  • Date/Location: The study covers legislative activities from late 1958 through 1960, centered in Washington, D.C., and focused on public domain lands in the state of Alaska. 

  • Archival Significance: Detailed case study of the Western Oil and Gas Association's lobbying operations; contains specific exploration cost data ($800 to $3,000 per day for geological parties); documents the transition of the Mineral Leasing Act of 1920 acreage limits from 100,000 acres to proposed million-acre allotments; provides a primary account of the "lobbying with facts" philosophy and the technical process of arranging Congressional hearings.

Publication Date

1-1961

Creative Commons License

Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License

Faculty Sponsor

Archive

Download

Share

COinS