Date of Award

10-2026

Document Type

Thesis

Degree Name

Master of Fine Arts in Art History and Visual Culture

Department

Art

First Advisor

James Hutson

Second Advisor

Steven J. Cody

Abstract

In this thesis, we will consider how 16th-century Venetian painters used sophisticated visual methods, colorito, glowing atmospheric glazes, serpentine lines and spatial buffering to camouflage the physical violence of Ovidian abduction stories. Most historical art literature in the past has hailed high Renaissance masters Titian and Paolo Veronese as technical bravura, lyrical colorism and visual appeal in the face of social and emotional tragedy in their work on canvas. In comparing Titian’s The Rape of Europa, Paolo Veronese’s The Rape of Europa, Paolo Veronese’s circle Scene from the Metamorphoses of Ovid: The Rape of Proserpine and Rembrandt Harmensz van Rijn’s Northern Baroque counterpoint, The Abduction of Proserpina, we come across three main visual mechanisms of mediation: spatial navigation, figure rotation and chromatic camouflage. Vector mapping shows that moving from the leftward “sinister” axis is a visual sign of structural instability, moral hazard and narrative collapse. On the other hand, figure rotation and middle ground staging help viewers get away from their immediate encounter with physical coercion. Venetian colorito is a surface camouflage, using glazed, bright colors and pastoral landscapes to make the suffering framed in visual aesthetics, so that narrative trauma seems to be taken as beauty instead of real trauma. In view of the intimate and highly gendered architecture of the Renaissance studiolo, camerino and royal piezas de audiencia, these mythological canvases were complex instruments of courtly exchange and privileged male collectors could display classical erudition and political genius, but that meant eroticized female suffering was visualized in the eyes of the viewer. For contemporary philosophical aesthetics, such as A.W. Eaton’s “ethical defect” and Ellie Jerome’s “objection from creepiness,” high visual polish cannot erase narrative assault, and this creates a cognitive strain. These formal strategies put the viewer in a morally unstable position and make them complicit in the voyeuristic gaze. In the presence of contemporary feminist reclamation and classical reception studies, this thesis critiques the historical suppression of female agency in poesie literature and shows how Venetian Ovidian painting in the 16th-century was a calculated visual system that mediated narrative violation through the seductive power of aesthetic form.

Research Highlights

  • Core Objective: Examines how sixteenth-century Venetian painters utilized visual rhetoric, colorito, atmospheric glazes, and spatial staging to camouflage narrative violence in Ovidian abduction myths, interrogating how formal painterly choices implicate the spectator in the ethics of the voyeuristic gaze.

  • Methodology & Corpus: Employs comparative formalist visual analysis, ethical aesthetics (specifically A.W. Eaton's "ethical defect" and Ellie Jerome's "objection from creepiness"), and feminist visual theory across a four-painting comparative corpus: Titian's The Rape of Europa (1559–1562), Paolo Veronese's The Rape of Europa (c. 1578), the workshop circle of Paolo Veronese's Scene from the Metamorphoses of Ovid: The Rape of Proserpine (late 16th–17th century), and Rembrandt Harmensz van Rijn's Northern Baroque counterpoint The Abduction of Proserpina (c. 1631–1632).

  • Consolidated Findings: Vector mapping demonstrates that Titian's upward diagonal trajectory along the leftward "sinister" axis creates visual and moral instability, while Venetian colorito, luminous glazes, and open impasto serve as chromatic camouflage that envelops bodily trauma in sensory beauty; Paolo Veronese mitigates narrative trauma by organizing compositions into receding horizontal registers, relegating physical abduction to distant backgrounds, and employing inward figure rotation ("the view from behind") as an emotional buffer; the Veronese workshop circle utilizes middle-ground staging and serpentine linear rhythms to dissolve physical coercion into decorative landscape contours; Rembrandt eliminates atmospheric softening and spatial buffering, deploying harsh chiaroscuro and overt physical resistance to confront viewers directly with psychological terror and bodily violation.

  • Practical Implications: Asserts that Renaissance pictorial form is not ideologically neutral and cannot be assessed strictly through technical virtuosity or formalist praise; demonstrates that early modern display environments (studiolo, camerino, royal piezas de audiencia) converted gendered violence into intellectual and political currency for elite male patrons; establishes an art-historical framework integrating contemporary feminist reclamation and classical reception theory ("reading rape") to restore subjective agency and interiority to mythic female figures historically aestheticized as passive objects of consumption.

Creative Commons License

Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License

Download

Share

COinS